Bay Harbor Club Condos for Sale on Bonita Beach in Bonita Springs, Florida

Bay Harbor Club is a pair of 12-story condominium buildings on the bay side of Hickory Boulevard on Little Hickory Island in Bonita Springs. Owners get the best of both sides of the island: sunrise views over Estero Bay from their lanais, boat docks on the water and deeded access to Bonita Beach directly across the street.

Bay Harbor Club at a Glance

• Location: 26225 and 26235 Hickory Boulevard, Little Hickory Island, Bonita Springs
• Setting: bayfront on Estero Bay, across the street from the Gulf of Mexico
• Buildings: two 12-story towers with common elevators
• Residences: about 100
• Floor plans: mostly two bedrooms and two baths, about 1,300 to 1,475 square feet
• Built: 1980s
• Beach: deeded access to Bonita Beach
• Boating: boat docks on site

Bay Harbor Club Market Report

The snapshot below updates live from the MLS each time the page loads. For every active listing, condo under contract and sale from the last six months, see the full Bay Harbor Club Market Report.

Bayfront Living Across From the Beach

Bay Harbor Club sits right on the bay and channel, next door to Sea Isles. Mornings bring sunrise over Estero Bay. Many residences also take in Gulf views. When it is time for the beach, owners simply cross Hickory Boulevard to the sand. Deeded parking and deeded beach access come with ownership.

For boaters, the setting is hard to match. Boat docks on site put Estero Bay and the Gulf of Mexico within easy reach. A kayak launch makes paddling the back bay an everyday pleasure. Learn more in the boat access guide and the gulf access guide.

Amenities

• Heated pool and spa
• Elevated tennis and pickleball courts
• Bocce and shuffleboard
• Clubhouse
• Barbecue area
• Boat docks and kayak launch

The Residences

Most Bay Harbor Club residences have two bedrooms and two baths with about 1,300 to 1,475 square feet of living space. Common elevators serve both buildings. Many residences have wrap-around lanais. Owners have updated their homes over the years with impact windows and hurricane protection. Higher floors open up wider views across the bay, the mangrove islands and the Gulf.

Location

Bay Harbor Club is on Little Hickory Island, along Hickory Boulevard on Bonita Beach. Groceries are a short drive inland. Coconut Point shopping and dining are about 15 to 20 minutes away. Naples, Mercato and Southwest Florida International Airport are all within an easy drive.

Nearby Bonita Beach Condos

Buyers comparing Bay Harbor Club often look at its neighbor Sea Isles, as well as Silver Sands, Dolphin Way, Egret and The Ambassador. Compare them all in the Bonita Beach condos guide and the Bonita Springs high-rise condos guide.

Selling a Condo in Bay Harbor Club

Bayfront buildings on Bonita Beach compete for a specific buyer: someone who wants the beach and the boat in the same address. The residences that stand out are priced with precision, prepared with care and presented to the buyers most likely to value sunrise water views, a deeded dock and the beach across the street. Our team has sold condominiums in Bay Harbor Club and up and down Bonita Beach. Sellers here are not looking for a gimmick. They want strategy and sophisticated marketing.

Schedule a one-on-one listing strategy session. You can also start with the online home valuator.

A Local's View of Bay Harbor Club

A beautiful condominium in Bay Harbor Club is one I had the pleasure of selling. The seller reached out to me when she was ready to leave Florida. She had owned the condominium for quite some time. It was time to move on to her next adventure.

The unit had been lovingly reconditioned and professionally decorated. It was a great example of how a condominium can become a little oasis on the beach.

The buyers wanted something beautiful near the water. The bay view mattered to them, because at night you see twinkling lights in the distance. It is a little entertainment all its own. For them, this condo was a weekend getaway and a fun way to vacation with colleagues and friends who come to town with them.

It was an honor to serve both parties.

Bay Harbor Club FAQ

Where is Bay Harbor Club?

Bay Harbor Club is at 26225 and 26235 Hickory Boulevard on Little Hickory Island in Bonita Springs. The buildings sit on the bay side of Hickory Boulevard, across the street from Bonita Beach.

Does Bay Harbor Club have beach access?

Yes. Owners have deeded beach access to Bonita Beach, directly across Hickory Boulevard.

Can you keep a boat at Bay Harbor Club?

Bay Harbor Club is on the bay with boat docks on site. Ask about the availability of a deeded dock when you are looking at a residence.

How many residences are in Bay Harbor Club?

Bay Harbor Club has about 100 residences in two 12-story buildings.

What size are the condos at Bay Harbor Club?

Most residences have two bedrooms and two baths with about 1,300 to 1,475 square feet of living space.

Where can I see recent Bay Harbor Club sales?

The Bay Harbor Club Market Report shows condos for sale, under contract and sold in the last six months, updated from the MLS as condos list and sell.

What is my Bay Harbor Club condo worth?

Start with the online home valuator for a first read on value. For a precise price, schedule a one-on-one listing strategy session that compares your building, floor, view and dock with recent Bay Harbor Club sales.

To talk about buying or selling in Bay Harbor Club, call or text 239-273-7430, send a message or schedule a call.